Comparing the new YouTube HD with Vimeo SD

A few months ago I posted a shortcut that let you see better quality encodes from YouTube (add &fmt=18 to the end of the URL). That was part of YouTube re-encoding all their videos to a better codec: H.264.

They’ve now been re-encoding videos that were uploaded to YouTube at higher resolution than standard definition. On videos that are available in higher quality, you’ll see a link below the video: ‘Watch in high quality”

Normal quality:

High quality:

To see the differences zoom the videos to fill the screen. You’ll see that YouTube may be using the better resolution than SD uploaded but its users, but it isn’t displaying HD on it’s site or in embedded videos yet.

This sort of content seems tough for the Flash encoder. It isn’t been optimised to deal with primarily dark video. Although Vimeo is better, there are problems:

Of course in the case of Vimeo, you can click their logo to see the video in higher resolution on the Vimeo site, but even the SD embedded version looks better here. If I was based in the US, I could also have the option of paying $60 a year to have the HD versions of my videos embedded on my blog.

PS: If you want all the videos you see on the YouTube site to default to the higher quality version and you have an account, click ‘Account’, ‘Playback Setup’ and ‘I have a fast connection. Always play higher-quality video when it’s available.’

Followup 23 November, 2008 by Alex

As you can see from my comment below, YouTube is encoding 720p videos – an HD resolution. It just takes a few more hours for that version to be available.

  1. JR said:

    I use Vimeo for personal and the work with my non-profit. The list of advantages are even longer than simply embedding HD. I can group into albums and channels, create custom widgets and no ads for content that is outside the non-profit’s interests. I also have several options for levels of privacy including playing an embedded video only on a certain page.

  2. Alex said:

    The second Lightning one is fmt=22, but YouTube encoded my 1280 by 720 H264 QuickTime movie as a 480 by 270 H263 file for some reason. What was the format of the Intel Ad?

  3. Alex said:

    Oops, looks like YouTube encodes three versions. The standard version, the 480 by 270 h.263 version (&fmt=18) and the 1280 by 720 h.264 version (&fmt=22). It took 24 hours for the encoder to get around to doing the HD version.

  4. Rich said:

    There’s actually 4 versions of YouTube movies, plus I think they keep the original. Here’s the other, but I can’t remember why you trigger this setting:

    high quality “&fmt=06”
    (320 x 240, H.263 video, mono 16/44.1 at 96 Kbps)

Leave a Reply to Philip Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: